Does Context Matter?
In this activity, students will consider the meaning of an iconic photograph from Regarding Susan Sontag in a panel discussion, comparing historical, modern, and aesthetic perspectives on the image.
PHOTOGRAPHY LESSON 3: PANEL DISCUSSION
1—2 class periods (60-120 min)
VIDEOS:
On Photography Video and Transcript
HANDOUTS:
Handout 2 (as needed)
Handout 3/4 (as needed)
Unit Research (as needed)
WORKSHEET:
TEACHING PLAN:
- Art and Culture
Medium > Visual Arts
Subject Matter > Art History
- History and Social Studies
Place > The Americas
Place > Asia
Place > Europe
U.S. History
U.S. > Civil War
U.S. > The Great Depression and WWII
Themes > Exploration and Discovery
Themes > Civil Rights
Themes > Culture
Themes > War and Foreign Policy
World > The Modern World
- Literature and Language Arts
Genre > Essay
Place > Modern World
- Analysis
- Compare and contrast
- Critical thinking
- Cultural analysis
- Debate skills
- Discussion
- Evaluating arguments
- Gathering, classifying and interpreting written, oral and visual information
- Historical analysis
- Internet skills
- Interpretation
- Media analysis
- Making inferences and drawing conclusions
- Online research
- Oral analysis
- Oral communication
- Oral presentation skills
- Persuasive writing and speaking
- Representing ideas and information orally and graphically
- Research
- Summarizing
- Synthesis
- Technology
- Textual analysis
- Using archival documents
- Using primary sources
- Using secondary sources
- Visual analysis
- Visual art analysis
- ELA Reading: 1, 7
- ELA Writing: 7, 9
- ELA Speaking & Listening: 1-2, 4-6
- HSS Reading: 1-3, 6-10
- HSS Writing: 7, 9
LESSON 3 HANDOUTS
- Allow additional time for preparation of arguments (in-class or as an assignment) and panel discussions, asking students to research their photograph in more depth and reference specific findings in their response (see Photography Unit Research handout for related texts and resources), or to incorporate digital media into their presentations.
- Present panel discussions as a school or public forum (see our Information for Teachers), allowing additional time for introductions, presentations, roundtable discussion, and questions from the audience.
- Arguments may also be turned in as written summaries, response papers, or media presentations.